Design failures behind 40% of construction disputes

Design-related failures contributed to claims and disputes on more than 40% of construction and engineering projects examined in a global study, with nuclear and data centre developments facing particularly high levels of financial risk.

Global study of projects worth US$2.56 trillion reveals major risks facing nuclear, data centre and renewable energy construction Global study of projects worth US$2.56 trillion reveals major risks facing nuclear, data centre and renewable energy construction. Image: Adobe Stock

The ninth annual CRUX Insight report, published by consultancy HKA, analysed 2,410 projects across 122 countries, representing a combined investment of US$2.56 trillion.

The research found that design-related problems contributed to disputes on 40.5% of projects, including design errors (20.8%), late design information (19.7%) and incomplete designs (17.2%). Changes in project scope were another major cause, affecting 33.4% of projects.

Across the dataset, claims for additional costs averaged 33% of contract budgets, while claims for extensions of time amounted to 65.8% of planned project schedules.

HKA said the cumulative value of sums in dispute across the projects had reached US$100 billion.

Nuclear and data centre risks

Nuclear construction emerged as a particular area of concern, with sums in dispute on more recent projects averaging 122% of contracted budgets.

Late design information was identified as a cause of disputes on 41.7% of nuclear projects, with HKA pointing to political pressure to begin construction before planning and design work had been completed.

Data centre construction also showed significant financial pressures. Although claimed extensions of time fell from an average of 112% of planned schedules across the wider dataset to 67% on projects scheduled to complete from 2020 onwards, disputed costs increased from 20.6% to 30.2% of budgets.

The report identified incomplete and inaccurate designs, as well as difficulties installing complex building services and integrating critical systems, as major contributors to data centre project disputes.

Renewable energy projects faced different challenges, with unforeseen physical conditions affecting 23.7% of projects and restricted or delayed site access contributing to disputes on 18.7%.

HKA also highlighted problems involving inexperienced contractors, particularly in offshore wind cable installation, alongside supply chain constraints.

Despite these pressures, the research found evidence that project outcomes are improving. Across projects scheduled to complete from 2020 onwards, average claimed extensions of time fell to 48.8% of planned schedules, while contested costs declined to 28.4% of contract budgets.

HKA’s findings are based on projects involving claims or disputes investigated by its consultants, rather than a representative sample of all construction projects. The reported figures reflect amounts claimed or disputed, not necessarily final cost overruns or sums awarded.

Longer reads
How is Terex’s sale of Genie progressing?
Simon Meester, CEO of Terex, provides updates on the work to seperate Genie and its search for a buyer during Q3 earnings call 
Kobelco’s three objectives after buying 70% of CNH’s construction machinery arm
Japanese construction equipment manufacturer Kobelco has set out three objectives at the heart of its move to buy 70% of CNH Industrial’s construction machinery business
Different approaches to cranes and lifting for data centre construction
Prolific data centre construction is seeing different approaches to lifting
CONNECT WITH THE TEAM
Andy Brown Editor, Editorial, UK - Wadhurst Tel: +44 (0) 1892 786224 E-mail: [email protected]
Neil Gerrard Senior Editor, Editorial, UK - Wadhurst Tel: +44 (0) 7355 092 771 E-mail: [email protected]
Eleanor Shefford Brand Manager Tel: +44 (0) 1892 786 236 E-mail: [email protected]
Peter Collinson VP Sales – Construction Division Tel: +44 (0) 1892 786220 E-mail: [email protected]
CONNECT WITH SOCIAL MEDIA